The Freemason Forum



I cant help but wonder...

Posted By wolfy 22/06/2009 23:07:50
Add to Favorites0
Author Message
BroDFB
 Posted 16/07/2009 08:09:33
Journeyman

Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)Journeyman - (198 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 05/01/2012 11:49:19
Posts: 92, Visits: 1,789
198
M Perrott (16/07/2009)
Take for example Peter Clatworthy. His strong views are not my cup of tea, but at every masonic forum he has joined certain individuals have followed him, hounded him and made sure he leaves quickly.


IMHO, in Peter's case, it depends what you mean by hounding. I have had heated discussions on other fora but that is not the same as hounded.


Dave

PM & Secretary: Lodge of Triumph No. 1061 (W.Lancs)
Brigantes Lodge No. 9734 (C & W)
IPZ: St. Annes Chapter No. 2457 (W.Lancs)
MWS: Fylde Rose Croix No. 1085
James Edward Glover RCC No. 451
"It may disturb you, It scares the willies out of me!" :D
M Perrott
 Posted 16/07/2009 09:52:28
Master

Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 21/12/2011 00:19:49
Posts: 339, Visits: 2,530
573
BroDFB (16/07/2009)
M Perrott (16/07/2009)
Take for example Peter Clatworthy. His strong views are not my cup of tea, but at every masonic forum he has joined certain individuals have followed him, hounded him and made sure he leaves quickly.


IMHO, in Peter's case, it depends what you mean by hounding. I have had heated discussions on other fora but that is not the same as hounded.

I think quite a few people have had discussions with Peter about his often objectionable views about history, Grand Lodges and even the Supreme Council of the A&AR. And to be fair, I think he relished the confrontation for the most part.

I was referring to a specific group of individuals that took it upon themselves to aggressively bully him till he decided he could take no more.   

Roy V
 Posted 16/07/2009 14:57:39
Past Master

Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: Yesterday @ 13:42:01
Posts: 773, Visits: 1,439
993
M Perrott (16/07/2009)
Between 0215 hours and 0230 hours this morning, I received no less than 4 anonymous calls to my home number. Talk about tempting fate !!

Take for example Peter Clatworthy. His strong views are not my cup of tea, but at every masonic forum he has joined certain individuals have followed him, hounded him and made sure he leaves quickly.

Perish the thought that I am attempting to prolong this type of discussion, but do these anonymous people speak?  If so, you could be, with the help of the police you claim to have involved, record and trace the callers.  In which case, job done.

However, if there is merely a ringing which proves to be a dead line when it is picked up, and the number is witheld, that is no different from the erstwhile cold calls to my own home number, and are caused by call centres dialling several numbers at once, and speaking only to the first to answer.  This can be prevented by registering with the TPS.

However, if the time of day is significant, maybe there are persons in the antipodes who have serious issues with you - in which case, surely international numbers can still be traced by the authorities.

With reference to Grand Secretary Clatworthy, any man who acts in Eastenders has a lot to answer for!  But notwithstanding the attacks on him by the insidious DI supporters, he has not run away, but reigns supreme as the face of a certain form of Freemasonry, albeit imitating a loon at times, sometimes referring to "normal" FM as a state of fact; but mostly we are discarded as "pretend" Masons, not of his world.

No-one has hounded him away as far as I have seen, and they are pretty vicious individuals on that forum.

PM 5770

Middlesex

multisync
 Posted 16/07/2009 21:24:39
Fellow

Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)Fellow - (342 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 5 hours ago
Posts: 217, Visits: 3,131
342
I thought he was in Emmerdale?

3954
Alan Campbell
 Posted 16/07/2009 21:44:37
Past Master

Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 04/02/2012 12:02:46
Posts: 1,247, Visits: 2,228
The reason that I think he leaves is that no one believes him, What he has done is just silly. If you don't like the mainstream freemasonry then fine leave and start your own, that is his prerogative but don't then start saying that it is freemasonry in its original form and can claim its origins back to Athelstane 926 in an unbroken line.

I have never seen any posts in support of that theory and if it was me that ws being told that i am wrong all the time then i would probably have left as well.

lauderdale
 Posted 16/07/2009 22:13:01
Excellent Master

Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)Excellent Master - (2,476 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 10/07/2011 06:43:06
Posts: 2,136, Visits: 4,278
Emmerdale? Well he certainly wasn't in "Lauderdale"!

Seriously though, I have always got on well with Bro Peter Clatworthy of GLAE and although we have strongly disagreed on a couple of Masonic matters he is always welcome to post again on my Forum as I have always found him to be a courteous and well mannered man. He was not kicked off but left of his own free will and his account is still live.

M Perrott
 Posted 16/07/2009 23:14:43
Master

Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 21/12/2011 00:19:49
Posts: 339, Visits: 2,530
573
Roy V (16/07/2009)
M Perrott (16/07/2009)
Between 0215 hours and 0230 hours this morning, I received no less than 4 anonymous calls to my home number. Talk about tempting fate !!

Take for example Peter Clatworthy. His strong views are not my cup of tea, but at every masonic forum he has joined certain individuals have followed him, hounded him and made sure he leaves quickly.

Perish the thought that I am attempting to prolong this type of discussion, but do these anonymous people speak?  If so, you could be, with the help of the police you claim to have involved, record and trace the callers.  In which case, job done.

They always speak, and ask for me by name "Brother Perrott" if I do not answer the phone. I usually don't, someone else does. If I do answer the phone second or third calling, the line goes dead. Number withheld. The Police will only take it further if the voice is threatening or abusive. It is sometimes male, sometimes female but never abusive or aggressive. The Police are involved in the other matters.

However, if there is merely a ringing which proves to be a dead line when it is picked up, and the number is witheld, that is no different from the erstwhile cold calls to my own home number, and are caused by call centres dialling several numbers at once, and speaking only to the first to answer.  This can be prevented by registering with the TPS.

Thanks for that, I work with offshore and inland callcentres for my job, I know the drill. The patterns do not conform, and BT have confirmed that and that the callers are UK based.. They will not disclose which numbers are calling, at least to me.

 

However, if the time of day is significant, maybe there are persons in the antipodes who have serious issues with you - in which case, surely international numbers can still be traced by the authorities.

The time of day is only significant due to the nuisance factor.

With reference to Grand Secretary Clatworthy, any man who acts in Eastenders has a lot to answer for!  But notwithstanding the attacks on him by the insidious DI supporters, he has not run away, but reigns supreme as the face of a certain form of Freemasonry, albeit imitating a loon at times, sometimes referring to "normal" FM as a state of fact; but mostly we are discarded as "pretend" Masons, not of his world.

No-one has hounded him away as far as I have seen, and they are pretty vicious individuals on that forum.

DI Forum? Not mentioned that place. It was not DI forumites that were attacking him, it was "masons". Some would say you get back what you give. In his case, I think his treatment was unjust. But then who am I?;)

Edit: Roy, you have taken my words out of context also.  I have said all along I do not hold any brief for that particular GL, Peter Cltworthy or his views. In fact I disagree with virtually everything he stands for. The point of mentioning him was on the level of tolerance and what happens to those that fall foul of the masonic forum clique "elite".

Roy V
 Posted 17/07/2009 07:02:57
Past Master

Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)Past Master - (993 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: Yesterday @ 13:42:01
Posts: 773, Visits: 1,439
993
M Perrott (16/07/2009)
[b]

Take for example Peter Clatworthy. His strong views are not my cup of tea, but at every masonic forum he has joined certain individuals have followed him, hounded him and made sure he leaves quickly.

 [quote]However, if the time of day is significant, maybe there are persons in the antipodes who have serious issues with you - in which case, surely international numbers can still be traced by the authorities.

The time of day is only significant due to the nuisance factor.

DI Forum? Not mentioned that place. It was not DI forumites that were attacking him, it was "masons". Some would say you get back what you give. In his case, I think his treatment was unjust. But then who am I?;)

Edit: Roy, you have taken my words out of context also.  I have said all along I do not hold any brief for that particular GL, Peter Cltworthy or his views. In fact I disagree with virtually everything he stands for. The point of mentioning him was on the level of tolerance and what happens to those that fall foul of the masonic forum clique "elite".

I did not intend to take any words in or out of context.  "Grand Sec" was mentioned in the context of being hounded off a forum - I have seen him attacked on a forum by outright nutcases, and he stands his ground.  But he has capitulated when faced with arguments on "home ground"?

As for context, the significance of "time of day" was merely to ask whether the people calling were from a different time zone, or felt so strongly they bothered to get up in the middle of the night themselves.  You have confirmed the latter.

Wilful misunderstanding only leads to prolonged arguments and then more acrimony, so I will end it here.

PM 5770

Middlesex

Mike Martin
 Posted 17/07/2009 09:39:48
Excellent Master

Excellent Master - (2,755 reputation)

Group: Administrator
Last Active: 51 minutes ago
Posts: 2,321, Visits: 11,819
I think it's time to remind everyone that there is an entente cordiale (since shortly after the birth of MFOL) not to allow complaining and negativity about other Masonic Forums and to point any people back to those Forum's Admin/Moderators to make such complaints.

So if I can ask you all not to discuss other Forums negatively here, or if you you must, take it to those Forums. I will have to start deleting posts that do so.

 Mike
Mersey Lodge No. 5434 Website
The Freemasons'''' Grand Charity Website
See my BALLS here
M Perrott
 Posted 17/07/2009 10:26:20
Master

Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)Master - (573 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 21/12/2011 00:19:49
Posts: 339, Visits: 2,530
573
Sorry Mike. The comments made were not about other Forums as per title, but an attitude in general that sometimes prevails across the boards.

Similar Topics

Expand / Collapse

Back To Top