The Freemason Masonic Regalia & Accessories
  • Home
  • Regalia
    • Craft
      • Craft Member
      • Craft Provincial
      • Craft Grand
    • RA Chapter
      • RA Member
      • RA Provincial
      • RA Grand
    • Mark & RAM
      • Mark Member
      • Mark Provincial
      • Mark Grand
      • Royal Ark Mariner
    • Knight Templar & Malta Degrees
      • Knights Templar
      • Knights of Malta
      • HRA Knights Templar Priests
    • Other Degrees Degrees
      • Rose Croix
      • Red Cross of Constantine
      • Royal and Select Masters
      • Order of the Secret Monitor
      • Allied Masonic Degrees
      • Royal Order of Scotland
  • Publications
    • Rituals
      • Craft
      • RA Chapter
      • Mark & RAM
      • Knight Templar & Knight Malta
      • Red Cross of Constantine & Rose Croix
      • Royal & Select Masters
      • Other Degree & Orders
    • Suggested Reading
      • Prospective Member
      • Moving to a new Office
      • Approaching the Chair
      • Beyond the Craft
    • General
      • General Reading
      • Speech Making and Humour
      • Handbooks
      • Lodge Administration
    • Other
      • Music
      • DVD
  • Jewellery
    • General
      • Rings
      • Cufflinks
      • Watches
      • Pendants & Charms
      • Lapel Pins / Tie tacs
    • Bespoke Jewellery
      • Lodge Cufflinks
      • Bespoke Rings
      • Engraving
  • Cases
  • Clothing
  • Furnishings
  • Gifts
  • Offers

The Freemason Forum

Home Tags
Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
Latest Posts Popular Topics

Home » General » Masonic History (Legends -V- Fact) » Why do some Freemasons think we have a Knights Templar connction?

Why do some Freemasons think we have a Knights Templar connction?

Posted By Mike Lawrence 12/05/2009 07:38:55
Add to Favorites1
POST REPLY
LIKE
0
Page 6 of 18 «« « 4 5 6 7 8 » »»

Why do some Freemasons think we have a Knights Templar connction?

  • Flat Ascending
  • Flat Descending
  • Threaded
Topic View Topic View
  • Add To Favorites
  • Print This Topic
  • Goto Topics Forum
Topic Options Topic Options
Author Message
Alan Campbell
 Posted 21/09/2009 18:43:52
Past Master

Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)Past Master - (1,391 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 04/02/2012 12:02:46
Posts: 1,247, Visits: 2,228
1,391
Theres seems to be a lot of talk about concrete evidence here and i still don't see any. To me ramsays oration can not be taken as fact it is a romanticism to try and ingratiate himself with the french court. I don't know if there is any definite proof, so to me it has to come down to a believe only.

To quote our rituals is also incorrect, we understand that the degrees are symbolic and not fact, especially the 3rd degree and the hiramic legend, so why would we count the KT's degrees as anything different.

REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
AJM
 Posted 21/09/2009 18:48:33
Apprentice

Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 16/06/2011 14:48:33
Posts: 33, Visits: 445
93
Ramsey never mentioned the Knights Templar.

________________________________________________________
Official Website
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
dp
 Posted 21/09/2009 19:25:54
Past Master

Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 08/01/2012 18:59:22
Posts: 1,082, Visits: 3,065
1,259
AJM (21/09/2009)
Ramsey never mentioned the Knights Templar.

That's right, he said something along the lines of "Descended from a line of Chilvery" Although I haven't seen his oration for a long while.

And whilst there have been some good arguments, there is no proof of a direct link (outside your work) between Freemasonry and the Knights Templar.

Most early high degrees created in France are a reaction by the Jacobites to the creation of the Hanovian backed English Grand Lodge.

As I said I can't really comment on other Templar degrees such as ROS, or I could but not with and first hand evidence!

As far as I am aware the most removed and traceable Templarish degree is CBCS which was an attempt to preserve Martinism and had nothing to do with KT perse...

REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
AJM
 Posted 22/09/2009 09:26:45
Apprentice

Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 16/06/2011 14:48:33
Posts: 33, Visits: 445
93
Ramsey is often cited as the first hint at Templarism within Freemasonry. Without going into too much detail, there are stronger written ties long before it. Shortly before Schaw (1598-99) in fact.



________________________________________________________
Official Website
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
dp
 Posted 22/09/2009 09:42:11
Past Master

Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)Past Master - (1,259 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 08/01/2012 18:59:22
Posts: 1,082, Visits: 3,065
1,259
Anyway, Ramsey didn't give proof.

I could say today that Freemasonry is descended from marshmallows that doesn't mean in 300 years someone could quote my statement as the first cited evidence...

REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
AJM
 Posted 22/09/2009 09:48:52
Apprentice

Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 16/06/2011 14:48:33
Posts: 33, Visits: 445
93
Please understand, I am not being coy and secretive. In fact I am extremely impatient to discuss it - at length - on the board.

My PR lady Suzy set up an official fanpage on facebook. I now provide regular updates there. Indeed, at least one fairly important update is imminent...


________________________________________________________
Official Website
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
AJM
 Posted 22/09/2009 09:52:45
Apprentice

Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 16/06/2011 14:48:33
Posts: 33, Visits: 445
93
dp (22/09/2009)
Anyway, Ramsey didn't give proof.


If he did, I wouldn't be hailed as the first to do so. ;)

You are quite correct. Ramsey just said/wrote something, offered no evidence, and it has been misunderstood ever since.


________________________________________________________
Official Website
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
cuthbert
 Posted 22/09/2009 10:09:00
Journeyman

Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 31/01/2012 21:21:46
Posts: 75, Visits: 252
115
AJM (22/09/2009)
Please understand, I am not being coy and secretive. In fact I am extremely impatient to discuss it - at length - on the board. All I can say is "watch this space".

My PR lady Suzy set up an official fanpage on facebook. I now provide regular updates there. Indeed, at least one fairly important update is imminent...

...and I'm EXTREMELY impatient to see you "tangible proof", brother.:P

Quite a lot of people, especially in the Continent, claim to have "proof" of that, they always refers to documents like lists of members of operative lodges in the XIIIth century, a pity that they never gave me access to these papers...:angry::P

SW, Kensington Lodge 1767

ASJ Chapter Forum 4423
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
cuthbert
 Posted 22/09/2009 10:20:37
Journeyman

Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)Journeyman - (115 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 31/01/2012 21:21:46
Posts: 75, Visits: 252
115
AJM (22/09/2009)
Sounds like a fraud to me Cuthbert! I had mine checked first...

Mmm, I'll make an example.

I know some italian freemasons who claim to have found a old list of members of an operative lodge in Bologna from 1248. In this list it seems that there are the names of two templar knights.

This document is supposed to be in custody of the University of Bologna, Faculty of Architecture, and the masonic researcher who supposely found it in the late 80s is a 33rd degree AASR and (in)famous professor of the University.

The story therefore sounds verosimile, the problem is that they always denied access to this document.

SW, Kensington Lodge 1767

ASJ Chapter Forum 4423
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information
AJM
 Posted 22/09/2009 10:29:11
Apprentice

Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)Apprentice - (93 reputation)

Group: Forum Member
Last Active: 16/06/2011 14:48:33
Posts: 33, Visits: 445
93
That sounds interesting. Pity access is denied. What is the source for this claim? A quick email to the university will clear it up. On my list of things to do! :)

The problem for me is that the inclusion of only two Templars doesn't necessarily indicate a strong link between the two orders. Saying that, it is (or would be if it were true) a nice bit of research.


________________________________________________________
Official Website
REPLY
QUOTE
LIKE
0
Post Information

POST REPLY
LIKE
0
Page 6 of 18 «« « 4 5 6 7 8 » »»

Similar Topics

Expand / Collapse

Back To Top

Powered By InstantForum.NET 2012 © 2012
Execution: 0.126. 16 queries. Compression Enabled.
  • Masonic Regalia
  • Books for Freemasons
  • Freemasonry Regalia
  • Knights Templar
  • Masonic Rings
  • Lodge Furnishings
  • Freemasonry Supplies